Which of the following is/are incorrect about solubility trend in group I & II?
B, C
Correct solubility order
Li2CO3 < Na2CO3 < K2CO3 < Rb2CO3 < Cs2CO3
This question tests your understanding of solubility trends for group I (alkali metals) and group II (alkaline earth metals) compounds. The key concept is that solubility depends on the balance between the lattice energy (the energy holding the ions together in the solid) and the hydration energy (the energy released when ions are surrounded by water molecules).
Let's analyze each statement step-by-step:
Step 1: Sulphates
The table states: Least soluble is BaSO4 and most soluble is BeSO4.
For group II sulphates (MSO4), solubility decreases down the group. Be2+ is a small ion with high hydration energy, which favors solubility. Ba2+ is a large ion; its compounds have high lattice energy, making them less soluble. BaSO4 is famously insoluble. This statement is correct.
Step 2: Hydroxides
The table states: Least soluble is LiOH and most soluble is CsOH.
For group I hydroxides (MOH), solubility increases down the group. Li+ is a small ion, so LiOH has high lattice energy, making it the least soluble hydroxide in group I. Cs+ is the largest ion, so CsOH has the lowest lattice energy and is the most soluble. This statement is correct.
Step 3: Fluorides
The table states: Least soluble is BaF2 and most soluble is BeF2.
For group II fluorides (MF2), the trend is the opposite of sulphates. Solubility increases down the group. BeF2 has a high lattice energy due to the small size of Be2+, making it the least soluble. BaF2 is relatively more soluble. Therefore, claiming BaF2 is the least soluble and BeF2 is the most soluble is incorrect.
Step 4: Carbonates
The table states: Least soluble is Cs2CO3 and most soluble is Li2CO3.
For group I carbonates (M2CO3), the solubility trend is not as simple. However, all group I carbonates are soluble in water. Li2CO3 is an exception; it is sparingly soluble due to the high lattice energy from the small Li+ ion. The carbonates of the heavier alkali metals (e.g., Na2CO3, K2CO3, Cs2CO3) are highly soluble. Therefore, Li2CO3 is the least soluble, and Cs2CO3 is among the most soluble. Claiming the opposite is incorrect.
Final Answer: The statements about Fluorides and Carbonates are incorrect.
Lattice Energy (ΔHlattice): The energy released when one mole of an ionic crystal is formed from its gaseous ions. It is inversely proportional to the size of the ions.
Hydration Energy (ΔHhyd): The energy released when one mole of gaseous ions is dissolved in water. It is directly proportional to the charge density (charge/size) of the ion.
Solubility: A salt dissolves if the hydration energy is sufficient to overcome the lattice energy.