Which of the following arrangements does not represent the correct order of the property stated against it?
On the basis of CFSE, stability of Co3+ is highest and stability of Sc3+ is minimum among Co+3 , Fe+3 , Cr+3 , Sc+3
Paramagnetic behaviour
V2+ < Cr2+ < Fe2+ < Mn2+
This question tests your understanding of periodic trends and properties of transition metal ions. Let's analyze each option step by step to identify which arrangement does NOT correctly represent the stated property.
Ionic size generally increases down a group and decreases across a period due to increasing effective nuclear charge. For isoelectronic ions (same number of electrons), size decreases with increasing atomic number. All these ions have the electronic configuration [Ar] 3dn.
Atomic numbers: Ni (28), Co (27), Fe (26), Mn (25). Since all are M2+ ions, ionic radius should increase as atomic number decreases. The correct order should be: Ni2+ (69 pm) < Co2+ (74 pm) < Fe2+ (78 pm) < Mn2+ (83 pm). This arrangement is correct.
Paramagnetic behaviour depends on the number of unpaired electrons. More unpaired electrons means greater paramagnetism.
Let's calculate unpaired electrons:
So the number of unpaired electrons: V1+ = Cr2+ = 4 < Mn2+ = 5 > Fe2+ = 4. Therefore, the order of paramagnetic behaviour should be: V1+ ≈ Cr2+ < Mn2+ > Fe2+. The given order V1+ < Cr2+ < Mn2+ < Fe2+ is incorrect because Fe2+ has fewer unpaired electrons than Mn2+.
Transition metals exhibit various oxidation states. Generally, the number of oxidation states increases across the period until the middle, then decreases.
Common oxidation states:
So the number of oxidation states: Sc (1) < Ti (3) < Cr (3) < Mn (5). This order is correct.
Stability in aqueous solution for M3+ ions is related to their hydration energy and lattice energy. Generally, smaller ions with higher charge are more stable due to greater hydration energy. The order of stability is often: Sc3+ < Cr3+ < Fe3+ < Co3+? Actually, Co3+ is unstable in water and oxidizes water, while Cr3+ is very stable. The correct order of stability is: Sc3+ < Fe3+ < Cr3+ (Co3+ is least stable). So the given order Co3+ < Fe3+ < Cr3+ < Sc3+ is incorrect, but we already found Option 2 is incorrect. However, Option 2 is clearly wrong based on unpaired electrons, making it the primary incorrect arrangement.
The arrangement that does not represent the correct order is Option 2: V1+ < Cr2+ < Mn2+ < Fe2+ for paramagnetic behaviour, because Fe2+ has fewer unpaired electrons (4) than Mn2+ (5), so it should be less paramagnetic.
Paramagnetism: Substances with unpaired electrons are attracted to a magnetic field. The magnetic moment is given by BM, where n is the number of unpaired electrons.
Ionic Size: For isoelectronic ions, size decreases with increasing nuclear charge: .
Oxidation States: Depend on the number of valence electrons and stability of half-filled or fully-filled orbitals.
Stability in Solution: Influenced by hydration energy, charge density, and tendency to oxidize/reduce.